Skip to content

Comparing starlette-admin, Django Admin, and Flask-Admin

Django Admin, Flask-Admin, and starlette-admin all solve the same core problem: they generate a production-ready administrative interface directly from your data models. This eliminates the need to write CRUD screens by hand. They differ primarily in their target web stacks, supported ORMs, and the balance of built-in features versus developer customization.

This page provides a comprehensive comparison. If you are already familiar with Django Admin or Flask-Admin and want a direct API translation, refer to the relevant migration guide:

Positioning at a Glance

Django Admin Flask-Admin starlette-admin
Web framework Django only Flask only Starlette, FastAPI, and any ASGI app capable of mounting sub-applications
Execution model Sync (WSGI-first) Sync (WSGI) Async-first (ASGI)
Data layer Django ORM only SQLAlchemy, MongoEngine, peewee, pymongo SQLAlchemy, SQLModel, MongoEngine, Beanie, Tortoise ORM, or a custom backend
UI toolkit Django templates, classic admin theme Bootstrap 2/3/4 Tabler (Bootstrap 5), dark mode, custom themes
Included with framework Yes, part of Django No, separate package No, separate package
Authentication Built in via django.contrib.auth Bring your own (is_accessible) Pluggable [AuthProvider / OAuthProvider](../user-guide/auth.md), bring your own user store

When Each Framework Fits

Django Admin

This is the ideal choice for native Django applications. It is mature and deeply integrated with django.contrib.auth. It provides users, groups, per-model permissions, and change history with zero configuration. However, it cannot be used outside of the Django ecosystem.

Flask-Admin

This library brought the auto-generation concept to Flask and popularized the ModelView configuration style. It remains synchronous and strictly tied to Flask. This limitation is significant if you are building on a modern asynchronous stack.

starlette-admin

This package targets the modern asynchronous Python stack. If your application uses FastAPI or Starlette, it mounts directly onto your app and runs natively on the async event loop. It supports both SQL and NoSQL data layers. It borrows the intuitive ModelView configuration from Flask-Admin while covering the feature depth expected by Django Admin users. This includes inlines, batch actions, per-request permissions, and internationalization.

Feature Matrix

Legend:

  • Yes: Built in
  • Partial: Possible via third-party packages or custom code
  • No: Not available
Feature Django Admin Flask-Admin starlette-admin
Auto-generated CRUD views Yes Yes Yes
Full-text search Yes search_fields Yes column_searchable_list Yes searchable_fields
Column filters Yes list_filter Yes column_filters Yes Visual filter builder with AND/OR groups
Sorting and default ordering Yes Yes Yes [sortable_fields, fields_default_sort](../user-guide/views.md#search-sort)
Inline editing in list view Yes list_editable Yes column_editable_list Yes inline_editable_fields
Related-model inline forms Yes TabularInline / StackedInline Yes inline_models Yes InlineModelView
Batch actions Yes actions Yes @action Yes @action with confirmation dialogs and custom forms
Per-row actions Partial custom templates Partial custom formatters Yes [@row_action, @link_row_action](../user-guide/actions.md#row-actions)
Data export Partial django-import-export Yes CSV and others Yes CSV, JSON, Excel, PDF
Data import Partial django-import-export No Yes CSV, JSON, Excel with preview validation and upsert
File and image uploads Yes FileField / ImageField Partial requires extra setup Yes Local and S3 storage
Dashboard widgets Partial third-party themes Partial custom index view Yes Built-in widget system
Custom standalone pages Yes custom AdminSite URLs Yes BaseView + @expose Yes CustomView
Form layout control Yes fieldsets Yes form_rules Yes form_layout with tabs and grids
Authentication Yes django.contrib.auth No bring your own Yes AuthProvider or OAuthProvider
Per-model permissions Yes permission framework Yes override can_* flags Yes per-request methods
Per-field permissions Partial get_readonly_fields No Yes can_access_field
Lifecycle hooks Yes save_model, signals Yes on_model_change Yes Lifecycle hooks and events
CSRF protection Yes Django middleware Yes via Flask-WTF Yes [Built into Admin](../user-guide/security.md)
Change history / audit log Yes LogEntry No Partial build using events
Internationalization Yes Yes via Flask-Babel Yes I18nConfig
Multiple admin instances Yes multiple AdminSites Yes Yes Multiple Admin mounts
Async ORM support Partial No Yes async SQLAlchemy, Beanie, Tortoise ORM

Trade-Offs

  • Complete user system: Django Admin includes a comprehensive user system out of the box. Users, groups, permissions, and password management are handled by django.contrib.auth automatically. starlette-admin requires you to implement authenticate() against your own data store. This demands more initial setup but provides greater architectural flexibility later.
  • Automated change history: Django Admin automatically records change history via LogEntry. In starlette-admin, you must build your own audit trail by subscribing to lifecycle events. This only requires a few lines of code, but it is not automatic.
  • Third-party ecosystem: Django Admin benefits from a massive ecosystem of third-party packages for themes, widgets, and data workflows. While starlette-admin includes many of these features natively, highly specialized niche extensions might not yet exist.
  • File management: Flask-Admin provides FileAdmin, a dedicated server file-system browser. starlette-admin handles files attached directly to model fields via local disk or S3, but it does not include a generalized server file manager.

Next Steps